Move over, fashionistas. This fall, the recessionistas are taking over.

Grist State of Emergency | A limited-run newsletter from Grist, exploring the ways climate disasters are reshaping elections. Delivered every Tuesday until Election Day.

Reader support helps sustain our work. Donate today to keep our climate news free.

With the economy unraveling like a Forever 21 sweater, terms like “recessionista” and “slow fashion” are popping up all over. Last month, a piece in Alabama’s Press-Register proclaimed, “Fall fashion 2008: The year of the recessionista,” and The New York Times devoted a recent style piece to the “recessionista” moniker, pronouncing it “A Label for a Pleather Economy.” Trendsetters are advised to hold clothing swaps and shop at thrift stores to score clothes that are new to them, if not brand-new.

Meanwhile, the admittedly small and elitist slow-fashion movement (inspired by Slow Food) is supposedly a burgeoning sea change from consumers scoring cheap, poorly constructed, and questionably sourced runway rip-offs. Slow fashion, says The Guardian, is all about investing in quality pieces of clothing that’ll hopefully last a long time; attention is paid to whether items are fair-trade, made locally, and made of organic material.

Grist thanks its sponsors. Become one.

Hmm. When I was in college, it wasn’t unusual to hit up the local Salvation Army for thrifty finds and supplement with some well-chosen, quality sweaters or jeans. Rather than having a trendy title, this was born out of a ramen-eating necessity. As for slow fashion, it sounds like something conscientious, sustainability-minded people have been doing for years: not buying crap you don’t need, and avoiding stuff probably made in a sweatshop.

More power to the fashion industry if these “trends” catch on, but a couple of questions arise: Isn’t slow fashion a bit of a contradiction? Isn’t fashion deplored by enviros for churning out season after season of must-haves that — by design — become out of date three months later? And during a recession, wouldn’t people be more likely to buy cheap clothing than feel motivated to save up for a $300 jacket? Furthermore, if slow fashion and being a “recessionista” are trends, won’t they be replaced by other trends in a few months’ time, or fade when the economy recovers?

Don’t get me wrong; I hope slow fashion moves past a teeny following and goes the way of slow food. Being a careful, globally minded shopper is something that should never go out of style.